Cheapest 1 oz Gold Buffalo over spot

The lowest premium on 1 oz gold buffalo right now is 3.0% over spot at Pinehurst Coins ($4,481.65). Across 14 dealers the median premium is 4.9%, a 7.4% spread between cheapest and priciest. Ranked live against a gold spot of $4,350.50/ozt.

1. 1Pinehurst Coins$50 American Gold Buffalo 1 oz Random Year Brilliant Uncirculated3.0%$4,481.65
2. 2Provident MetalsAmerican Buffalo 1 oz Gold Coin Random Year From: $4623.674.1%$4,528.67
3. 3Monument Metals1 Oz American Gold Buffalo (Random Date)4.1%$4,529.51
4. 4BullionStarGold Coin Buffalo 1oz 20264.3%$4,537.01
5. 5PIMBEX1 oz American Gold Buffalo Coin (Random Year)4.3%$4,540.43
6. 6Bullion Standard1 Oz Gold American Buffalo - BU (Random Year)4.4%$4,541.88
7. 7United Patriot Coin2026 1 oz American Gold Buffalo4.7%$4,554.23
8. 8Battalion Metals1 Ounce American Gold Buffalo5.2%$4,574.65
9. 9SD Bullion1 oz American Gold Buffalo Coin - Random Year5.5%$4,590.91
10. 10JM Bullion2026 1 oz American Gold Buffalo Coin (BU)6.0%$4,611.11
11. 11APMEX1 oz Gold Buffalo BU (Random Year) $4,671.09 As Low As7.4%$4,671.09
12. 12Bullion ExpressGold 1 oz American Buffalo (BU) – Random Year7.5%$4,678.86
13. 13US Gold Bureau1 oz $50 Gold American Buffalo Coin (Date Varies)7.7%$4,688.43
14. 14Summit Metals1 oz American Gold Buffalo (Random Year)10.4%$4,805.33

Prices are each dealer's cash/check/wire price and were captured Sep 11, 2026, 7:21 PM; premiums use the spot quote captured with each dealer price. Dealer inventory and pricing change constantly — always confirm the price on the dealer's own site before buying. See all live deals →